I think David A. Eisenberg, in “The Leveling of the American Mind”, National Affairs, number 69, Fall 2026, makes the case that nobility, or personal pursuit of goodness, is prevented by the competition between aristocracy and democracy, two materialisms. Eisenberg uses the prefix “Aristocr-” 48 times and “Democr-” 83 times. He uses “noble” as a value only twice, I think missing his own potential to discover: every human-being may and can choose to pursue if not perfect personal goodness before they die. That a person can pursue perfection was suggested by Yeshua, the Galilean political philosopher who lived 2000 years ago.
The Hebrew Bible
More than other literature I encountered, the Hebrew Bible
reports humankind’s failure, so far, to accept whatever constrains the consequences of human choice; in other
words, the laws of physics rather than competitive doctrine of God or the Lord.
At stake is pursuit of goodness during personal, unique lifetimes and as civic
humankind.
Ancient tribalism
Semitic-speaking
people in Mesopotamia, 4000 years ago, resisted ceremonial human sacrifice to
obtain meat and blood for priests who led idol worship. Terah, with son Abram,
traveled west and struggled to establish a kingdom grounded in animal
sacrifice. Abram’s offspring, through 4 spouses, originated internally competitive
Israel and associated tribes. Hope for national obedience to goodness never
panned out, and a faction speculated an anointed priest and king, who would
unite the tribes.
A small
faction speculated that Yeshua, the Aramaic-speaking advocate for goodness in
Galilee, 2000 years ago, was the anointed one. Their minority concluded that
Yeshua’s influence extends to everyone who adopts goodness as a life-time intention
and practice. But the vast majority of Judeo-Christian votaries reject Yeshua’s
influence. Instead, they vainly attempt to impose on the Lord power, authority,
and responsibility which physics assigns to humankind. Civic human beings may
and can reform their religions.
Key scripture
In my
usage “Hebrew Bible” neither began
with Mosaic law nor ended with the
sacking of Jerusalem’s temple in 70 CE nor with Roman, Eastern, or Asian canonization
of the Greek “New Testament”, in about 400 CE. Judeo Christian literature
continues to develop at an astounding pace.
Discovery using ineluctable
evidence enables pursuit of goodness. Ineluctable means, together, neither to
be changed, nor avoided, nor resisted. Development of belief cannot empower
discovery. An unfathomable body of literature expounds beliefs, such as blood
sacrifice to redeem mysterious souls. I work to influence people to humbly
accept whatever constrains the consequences of human choice, be it the Lord or
physics, in order to develop comprehension, intention, and performance of
goodness on earth.
Here’s a partial list of scripture which
empowers individuals and groups to discover the ineluctable truth in goodness
rather than badness and evil. Featured is Yeshua, who was controversially known
by contemporaries 2000 years ago, but became the object of religious
competition when church and state executed him, unjustly. Centuries of debate
led to a different entity, Jesus Christ, 400 years ago in Germany.
1.
Ancient political
philosophers affirmed Genesis 1:26-28: on earth, humankind is in charge.
a.
Individual
pursuit of goodness, Psalm 8:4–8, ends at
personal death: Psalm 8:6-7.
b.
Individuals and
nations are to cultivate and protect life on earth: Genesis 2:15.
2.
Later,
philosophers, citing human failure, attempted to impose religious doctrine on
the laws of physics.
a.
The Lord is in
charge of peace on earth: Genesis 4-6.
b.
The earth is the
Lord’s Psalm 24:1, Isaiah 2:4, and Micah.
c.
Some predicted an
anointed one from the house of David: Isaiah 9:6-7 and 11:1-9.
3.
Yeshua, the Galilean teacher 2000 years ago,
affirmed Genesis 1:26-28 regarding humankind:
a.
Humankind’s purpose is goodness: Matthew 19:4–5 and Mark 10:6–8.
b.
Everyone may choose goodness: Matthew 22:19–21.
c.
Be reliable: Luke 12:42-48 and Matthew 25:14-30.
d.
Human conflict resolution will not be divinely
corrected: Matthew 18:18.
e.
Practice humility rather than imposition or
arrogance: Mark 10:42–45.
f.
Effect goodness: Matthew 25:35–40 and Matthew 5:13–16.
g.
Accept authority: Luke 10:19 and Matthew
28:18-20.
h.
Take responsibility: Matthew 5:1–12,
Matthew 5:17 and Matthew 1:15-17
i.
Accept personal power,
authority, and responsibility: Matthew 5:48 and John 10:34.
j.
Yeshua fortified
his influence in Matthew 6:1, Luke 6:45, Matthew 7:21 and Luke 6:46, plus
Matthew 5:20.
4.
Three major traditions
hide Yeshua’s influence:
a.
Most Hebrews do
not feature Yeshua of Galilee, 2000 years ago, in their moral debate.
b.
Most Christians
substitute Pauline “Jesus” for Yeshua, the person. The Greeks added the title,
Christ.
i.
The purpose is
antinomianism (mysterious salvation by gift) rather than pursuit of goodness.
ii.
Jesus Christ
purports salvation of souls in afterdeath more than goodness during life.
c.
Most scholars who
observed Yeshua’s influence to goodness did not know enough to address the
development of Jesus Christ, a religious figure which swamped the world, so
far. See the paragraph about scholars, below.
5.
The Constitution
for the United States republic, ratified on December 15, 1791, wholly
accommodates both Genesis 1:26-28 and Yeshua’s influence to goodness.
a.
The unique United States republic accommodates
the pursuit of goodness.
b.
Neglecting goodness nourishes badness and
invites evil.
c.
The intention is “to ourselves and our Posterity”.
I am not the first person who argued Yeshua was not divine: many
scholars noticed. Mara bar
Serapion placed him alongside Socrates and Pythagoras. Karl Jaspers
included him alongside Socrates, Buddha, and Confucius. Hannah Arendt
highlighted his political and ethical insights. Leo Tolstoy
noted his nonviolent resistance to state coercion. John Howard
Yoder wrote that his pacifism and servant leadership were a
deliberate, radical political alternative to the Roman Empire. Gustavo Gutiérrez
viewed his focus on the poor and marginalized as a foundational political
philosophy aimed at dismantling systemic economic oppression. Marcus Borg
portrayed Yeshua as a peasant Jewish sage who critiqued the Roman domination
system and economic exploitation. Thomas
Jefferson recognized Jesus as
a supreme moral teacher and ethical philosopher rather than a divine figure,
the Son of God, or a systematic political theorist. Ralph Waldo Emerson wrote
that he was a man. George W.
Bush famously named "Christ" as his favorite political
philosopher. I opine that Yeshua was an actual person, whereas Jesus is a
depiction. Eisenberg’s scholarly references have other political interests, perhaps
social democracy rather than goodness.
I am constrained to ask: How could Eiesenberg’s well-developed essay
miss the point: humankind’s purpose is to nourish goodness on earth. What is
the object of Eisenberg’s longing? Social democracy? Shockingly, humankind alienates
goodness by re-hashing, arguing, and warring over obsolete traditions. Tragically,
the victims are humankind’s children, whose opportunity to choose goodness
should be promoted, preserved, and defended by every adult.
Eisenberg’s intentions
A scholar’s
intentions may be suggested by word usage. Eisenberg used aristocracy, aristocratic,
nobility, estate, inherit, primogeniture, and property, 70 times, altogether.
He then juxtaposed democracy, democratic, democratization, and equality in 93
uses. He only mentioned communistic, fascistic, dissident, and socialistic
states. Tellingly his essay does not use
the word republic. Eisenberg cites Tocqueville’s prediction of a possible
better future using education, enlightenment, freedom, good, intellect,
liberty, literacy, opportunity, outcomes, providential, Tocqueville (champion),
and values 117 times, total.
I think Eisenberg’s premise is that extant declining-education-quality favors the wealthy, and subjective citizens train for the jobs the nation thinks it needs, right or wrong. The satisfied wealthy don’t pursue nobility as integrity. Consequently, even though education is ubiquitous, the American intellect is in decline; integrity is in decline.
Three exaggerations
Tocqueville’s opinions are not the ineluctable truth.
First, the Puritans cannot be held
exemplary dissidents when they copied European precedents to conduct the Salem “witch”
executions of 1692. Contemporaneous European executions number in the tens of
thousands.
Second, the American South cannot be held responsible for slavery when 6 European nations conducted the Atlantic slave trade, placing the purchased-captives in European colonies in America. America was neither a nation nor a republic but a collection of European colonies during its enslavement.
Third, Tocqueville’s scholarship in no way empowered him to judge gross ignorance. And no one can equate the Unite States republic with democracy.
Land not the only property
Each individual is valued on merit,
and their accomplishments are their property. Hence, the phrase, “life,
liberty, and pursuit of happiness”.
Diligent humility is a property,
which facilitates acceptance of the power, authority, and responsibility to
pursue goodness on earth. Thereby, the individual may blend “Mother Earth”,
“the biblical God (goodness?)”, and actual-reality, in order to benefit from
that power which constrains the consequences of human choice. The greatness of
man is the ability to choose goodness and perfect the practice before dying.
Intellect is a property which motivates civic persons to earn their keep so as not to depend on a bureaucrat. Serving a public function is sufficient, and leisure time may be used to nourish intellect. If a person wants to earn wealth, they may choose entrepreneurship with its rewards and risks. There may be little time for relaxation let alone nourishing intellect. Civic people do all they can to preserve and defend each other’s opportunity to pursue goodness in their lives. The civic customer appreciates the civic entrepreneur.
Confronting social falsehoods
Civic citizens are not arrogant. The civic faction practices goodness, preserving the
opportunity for passives, dissidents, rebels, spirituals, criminals, and the
wicked to reform before they die. The civic faction aids civil annihilation of
evil. The civic faction observes the laws of physics.
For humankind to survive,
civic individuals may and can strive to maintain public status close to the
reforming citizens from each group: passives,
dissidents, rebels, spirituals, criminals, and the wicked. In other words, all
citizens who pursue civic integrity comprise a civic nation.
Literacy is no panacea for ignorance. For example, biblical reading can keep someone bemused in mystery for life. Belief stymies if not stamps-out discovery. I speculate that something constrains the consequences of human choice. If pressed to opine what it is, I guess the laws of physics and its progeny, including psychology.
I write opinion, because I do not know the ineluctable truth.
Cute sayings respond to Eisenberg’s essay
Without the United States republic,
democrats would enslave themselves.
More than freedom, goodness is the
human reason to be.
A viable human lifetime facilitates
personal choice to pursue perfect goodness.
A lifetime of making pinheads frees
personal intellect for self-development unto goodness.
Prayer for God to resolve conflict
on earth attempts to persuade usurpation of human duty.
No comments:
Post a Comment
I want your opinion and intend to respond.